| #3 | (1) | WI Whitewater | lost to | #1 | (4) | WI River Falls | 14 | to | 52 |
| #15 | (10) | Williams | lost to | #10 | (13) | Wesleyan CT | 28 | to | 34 |
| #2 | (2) | WI LaCrosse | beat | #17 | (15) | WI Stout | 31 | to | 14 |
| #7 | (9) | WI Platteville | beat | #19 | (16) | WI Oshkosh | 21 | to | 14 |
| #12 | (17) | Colby | beat | #26 | (21) | Tufts | 33 | to | 6 |
| #6 | (7) | Johns Hopkins | beat | #28 | (22) | Muhlenberg | 47 | to | 26 |
| #4 | (3) | Trinity CT | beat | #29 | (27) | Amherst | 14 | to | 7 |
| #11 | (11) | Bethel MN | beat | #52 | (38) | Concordia Mhd | 55 | to | 9 |
| #60 | (49) | College of NJ | lost to | #44 | (58) | Rowan | 30 | to | 44 |
| #25 | (30) | Carleton MN | beat | #66 | (62) | Augsburg | 48 | to | 17 |
| #43 | (61) | WI Stevens Pt | beat | #70 | (63) | WI Eau Claire | 39 | to | 36 |
| #14 | (19) | Berry | beat | #67 | (66) | Centre | 31 | to | 13 |
| #33 | (41) | Augustana IL | beat | #76 | (70) | IL Wesleyan | 42 | to | 21 |
| #51 | (60) | Randolph-Macon | beat | #84 | (71) | Shenandoah | 31 | to | 14 |
| #16 | (20) | St John's MN | beat | #77 | (73) | Gust Adolphus | 31 | to | 13 |
| #21 | (26) | Alma | beat | #75 | (74) | Trine | 42 | to | 28 |
| #35 | (37) | Carnegie Mellon | beat | #82 | (77) | Dickinson | 70 | to | 29 |
| #26 | (31) | Middlebury | beat | #86 | (81) | Hamilton | 24 | to | 21 |
| #59 | (45) | Bates | lost to | #65 | (84) | Bowdoin | 9 | to | 17 |
| #8 | (8) | Hardin-Simmons | beat | #83 | (89) | Howard Payne | 54 | to | 24 |
| #45 | (55) | Ohio Northern | beat | #95 | (91) | Mt St Joseph | 49 | to | 42 |
| #56 | (67) | Coe | beat | #96 | (93) | Dubuque | 19 | to | 7 |
| #5 | (5) | N Central IL | beat | #91 | (99) | Carroll WI | 64 | to | 7 |
| #37 | (43) | Belhaven MS | beat | #106 | (102) | S Virginia | 41 | to | 19 |
| #39 | (42) | M Hardin-Baylor | beat | #107 | (104) | E Texas Bap | 62 | to | 14 |
| #64 | (75) | Millsaps | beat | #123 | (108) | SW Univ TX | 27 | to | 24 |
| #23 | (25) | Chris Newport | beat | #116 | (110) | Montclair St | 49 | to | 42 |
| #55 | (57) | Hanover | beat | #129 | (112) | Bluffton | 48 | to | 0 |
| #79 | (95) | Utica | beat | #126 | (115) | St John Fisher | 31 | to | 7 |
| #49 | (53) | Linfield | beat | #131 | (117) | Lewis & Clark | 29 | to | 21 |
| #124 | (106) | Wilmington OH | lost to | #100 | (119) | Marietta | 14 | to | 44 |
| #94 | (103) | TX Lutheran | beat | #136 | (120) | McMurry | 42 | to | 13 |
| #40 | (40) | Baldwin-Wallace | beat | #125 | (121) | Muskingum | 35 | to | 28 |
| #38 | (39) | Wabash | beat | #127 | (122) | Wittenberg | 28 | to | 21 |
| #72 | (88) | Coast Guard | beat | #138 | (125) | Salve Regina | 36 | to | 31 |
| #89 | (69) | Brevard | lost to | #101 | (126) | Huntingdon | 26 | to | 32 |
| #50 | (54) | Susquehanna | beat | #134 | (127) | W Connecticut | 34 | to | 0 |
| #71 | (87) | Simpson IA | beat | #139 | (128) | Loras | 28 | to | 27 |
| #34 | (34) | Whitworth | beat | #133 | (129) | Pac Lutheran | 10 | to | 6 |
| #22 | (24) | Trinity TX | beat | #132 | (130) | Sewanee | 32 | to | 3 |
| #103 | (92) | Benedictine IL | lost to | #109 | (131) | St Norbert | 17 | to | 24 |
| #108 | (113) | Lycoming | beat | #144 | (132) | Catholic | 38 | to | 12 |
| #48 | (52) | Adrian | beat | #143 | (133) | Kalamazoo | 34 | to | 7 |
| #115 | (134) | Monmouth IL | beat | #147 | (137) | Chicago | 29 | to | 0 |
| #102 | (107) | King's PA | beat | #151 | (138) | Albright | 24 | to | 14 |
| #24 | (23) | Hope | beat | #137 | (139) | Albion | 62 | to | 0 |
| #92 | (80) | St Olaf | lost to | #114 | (140) | Macalester | 6 | to | 27 |
| #122 | (135) | St Scholastica | beat | #150 | (141) | Hamline | 49 | to | 18 |
| #41 | (35) | Washington StL | beat | #141 | (142) | Millikin | 38 | to | 7 |
| #110 | (90) | Lebanon Val | lost to | #121 | (143) | Stevenson | 13 | to | 15 |
| #73 | (82) | Wash & Jeff | beat | #148 | (146) | Case Western | 28 | to | 17 |
| #69 | (72) | Cal Lutheran | beat | #154 | (149) | Claremont M.S. | 21 | to | 18 |
| #118 | (97) | Carthage | lost to | #130 | (151) | North Park | 10 | to | 14 |
| #20 | (18) | Salisbury | beat | #153 | (154) | Wm Paterson | 51 | to | 7 |
| #32 | (28) | Frank & Marsh | beat | #155 | (155) | McDaniel | 24 | to | 3 |
| #46 | (44) | DePauw | beat | #159 | (159) | Ohio Wesleyan | 40 | to | 10 |
| #47 | (47) | Calvin | beat | #168 | (162) | Olivet MI | 50 | to | 20 |
| #119 | (144) | Brockport St | beat | #167 | (163) | Alfred | 51 | to | 0 |
| #57 | (50) | Eastern Univ | beat | #170 | (164) | Widener | 35 | to | 0 |
| #42 | (36) | Maryville TN | beat | #163 | (166) | Rhodes | 42 | to | 22 |
| #53 | (51) | Chapman | beat | #169 | (167) | Pomona-Pitzer | 22 | to | 14 |
| #9 | (6) | Mt Union | beat | #158 | (168) | Capital | 65 | to | 17 |
| #85 | (85) | Wilkes | beat | #180 | (171) | Juniata | 38 | to | 7 |
| #80 | (83) | Ursinus | beat | #175 | (172) | Gettysburg | 40 | to | 13 |
| #105 | (111) | Roanoke | beat | #179 | (173) | Guilford | 21 | to | 20 |
| #36 | (33) | Central IA | beat | #172 | (174) | Buena Vista | 52 | to | 27 |
| #145 | (150) | Northwestern MN | beat | #187 | (175) | Martin Luther | 24 | to | 17 |
| #117 | (116) | Wooster | beat | #186 | (176) | Kenyon | 49 | to | 6 |
| #74 | (76) | Heidelberg | beat | #181 | (178) | Otterbein | 69 | to | 13 |
| #112 | (114) | Aurora | beat | #185 | (179) | WI Lutheran | 49 | to | 42 |
| #104 | (109) | Westminster PA | beat | #188 | (180) | Allegheny | 57 | to | 21 |
| #30 | (29) | LaGrange | beat | #174 | (185) | Greensboro | 49 | to | 20 |
| #142 | (152) | MIT | beat | #189 | (186) | Worcester Tech | 19 | to | 7 |
| #13 | (12) | Wartburg | beat | #173 | (187) | NE Wesleyan | 34 | to | 10 |
| #152 | (136) | Rochester NY | lost to | #160 | (188) | Hobart & Smith | 21 | to | 28 |
| #165 | (169) | Kean | beat | #193 | (189) | Castleton | 14 | to | 9 |
| #194 | (184) | Framingham St | lost to | #171 | (190) | Plymouth St | 26 | to | 28 |
| #135 | (145) | NC Wesleyan | beat | #192 | (191) | Methodist | 48 | to | 17 |
| #62 | (64) | Cortland St | beat | #184 | (192) | Alfred St | 49 | to | 7 |
| #18 | (14) | Wheaton IL | beat | #178 | (193) | Elmhurst | 65 | to | 0 |
| #146 | (161) | Curry | beat | #201 | (195) | Husson | 40 | to | 21 |
| #140 | (148) | Crown MN | beat | #195 | (196) | MN Morris | 34 | to | 15 |
| #120 | (123) | Franklin | beat | #196 | (197) | Anderson IN | 41 | to | 7 |
| #88 | (86) | U New England | beat | #197 | (199) | Nichols | 58 | to | 34 |
| #78 | (79) | Denison | beat | #207 | (200) | Oberlin | 62 | to | 9 |
| #58 | (56) | Redlands | beat | #202 | (202) | La Verne | 29 | to | 14 |
| #162 | (170) | Pacific OR | beat | #216 | (203) | Puget Sound | 52 | to | 35 |
| #99 | (96) | Delaware Val | beat | #212 | (205) | Alvernia | 43 | to | 10 |
| #190 | (177) | Concordia IL | lost to | #200 | (206) | Lakeland | 16 | to | 47 |
| #113 | (118) | Hendrix | beat | #209 | (208) | Centenary | 64 | to | 10 |
| #54 | (48) | Hampden-Sydney | beat | #205 | (209) | Gallaudet | 61 | to | 8 |
| #90 | (98) | Rensselaer | beat | #208 | (210) | St Lawrence | 48 | to | 0 |
| #61 | (59) | Grove City | beat | #210 | (211) | St Vincent | 59 | to | 14 |
| #93 | (94) | Washington & Lee | beat | #215 | (214) | Averett | 61 | to | 21 |
| #219 | (207) | Austin Col | lost to | #203 | (216) | Lyon | 28 | to | 40 |
| #81 | (68) | Misericordia | beat | #220 | (217) | FDU Madison | 35 | to | 16 |
| #199 | (194) | Hiram | lost to | #211 | (218) | Thiel | 20 | to | 48 |
| #198 | (212) | Hartwick | beat | #225 | (220) | Morrisville St | 24 | to | 13 |
| #164 | (165) | Rose-Hulman | beat | #226 | (222) | Manchester | 35 | to | 13 |
| #177 | (153) | Greenville | lost to | #214 | (223) | Westminster MO | 7 | to | 24 |
| #98 | (100) | Ithaca | beat | #222 | (224) | Buffalo St | 49 | to | 7 |
| #157 | (158) | George Fox | beat | #228 | (225) | Willamette | 31 | to | 9 |
| #87 | (78) | Springfield | beat | #224 | (227) | Norwich | 48 | to | 6 |
| #223 | (226) | Bridgewater MA | beat | #232 | (229) | Fitchburg St | 38 | to | 18 |
| #217 | (221) | Cornell IA | beat | #231 | (230) | Knox | 35 | to | 14 |
| #183 | (183) | Waynesburg | beat | #230 | (231) | Bethany WV | 48 | to | 28 |
| #68 | (65) | Concordia WI | beat | #229 | (232) | Rockford | 35 | to | 0 |
| #213 | (213) | MA Maritime | beat | #235 | (233) | Westfield St | 21 | to | 14 |
| #156 | (156) | Illinois Col | beat | #233 | (234) | Grinnell | 14 | to | 7 |
| #111 | (105) | Union NY | beat | #234 | (235) | Hilbert | 34 | to | 13 |
| #161 | (157) | Anna Maria | beat | #237 | (236) | Worcester St | 45 | to | 35 |
| #166 | (160) | W New England | beat | #236 | (237) | N England Col | 55 | to | 0 |
| #191 | (198) | Lake Forest | beat | #239 | (238) | Lawrence | 72 | to | 0 |
| #206 | (204) | Ripon | beat | #240 | (239) | Beloit | 49 | to | 0 |
| #63 | (46) | Endicott | beat | #238 | (240) | ME Maritime | 69 | to | 7 |
| #218 | (215) | MA Dartmouth | beat | #241 | (241) | Dean | 48 | to | 7 |