| #4 | Butler | plays at | #7 | Morehead St |
| #10 | Davidson | plays | #1 | Presbyterian |
| #2 | Drake | plays | #6 | St Thomas MN |
| #9 | Marist | plays | #8 | Stetson |
| #7 | Morehead St | plays | #4 | Butler |
| #1 | Presbyterian | plays at | #10 | Davidson |
| #3 | San Diego | plays at | #11 | Valparaiso |
| #6 | St Thomas MN | plays at | #2 | Drake |
| #8 | Stetson | plays at | #9 | Marist |
| #11 | Valparaiso | plays | #3 | San Diego |