| Week | Rank | Rate | Record | SOS | Opponent | Score | Rank Then | Rank Now |
| 0 | 9 | 0.000 | (0,0) | 0.000 | --bye-- |
| 1 | 188 | 0.000 | (0,0) | 0.000 | --bye-- |
| 2 | 166 | 0.500 | (1,0) | -0.500 | Ohio Northern | 27 to 20 | 443 | 380 |
| 3 | 3 | 4.367 | (1,1) | 4.367 | Hope | 14 to 38 | 1 | 325 |
| 4 | 507 | -0.844 | (1,2) | -0.510 | Trine | 27 to 35 | 398 | 467 |
| 5 | 514 | -0.934 | (1,2) | -0.600 | --bye-- |
| 6 | 418 | -0.420 | (2,2) | -0.420 | Muskingum | 34 to 33 | 548 | 533 |
| 7 | 506 | -0.863 | (2,3) | -0.663 | Rose-Hulman | 34 to 35 | 556 | 611 |
| 8 | 498 | -0.827 | (3,3) | -0.827 | Manchester | 48 to 21 | 680 | 686 |
| 9 | 554 | -1.045 | (3,4) | -0.903 | Mt St Joseph | 21 to 52 | 483 | 514 |
| 10 | 548 | -1.028 | (4,4) | -1.028 | Anderson IN | 41 to 7 | 651 | 660 |
| 11 | 516 | -0.891 | (5,4) | -1.002 | Bluffton | 59 to 57 | 584 | 589 |
| 12 | 530 | -0.968 | (5,5) | -0.968 | Hanover | 18 to 51 | 401 | 388 |
| 13 | 548 | -1.040 | (5,5) | -1.040 | --bye-- |
| 14 | 543 | -1.002 | (5,5) | -1.002 | --bye-- |
| 15 | 548 | -0.994 | (5,5) | -0.994 | --bye-- |
| 16 | 539 | -0.974 | (5,5) | -0.974 | --bye-- |
| 17 | 538 | -0.971 | (5,5) | -0.971 | --bye-- |
| 18 | 538 | -0.971 | (5,5) | -0.971 | --bye-- |
| 19 | 539 | -0.974 | (5,5) | -0.974 | --bye-- |
| 20 | | | | | --bye-- |
| 21 | | | | | --bye-- |